About Us

Mayo Insurance has been serving clients since 1991 and has established a stellar reputation for service and professionalism. In 2006 we expanded our operations to include Williamsburg Insurance where we continue to serve clients with a high standard of quality and professionalism. In 2017 we added the Harbour View office, serving western Chesapeake, Suffolk and nearby areas. We are a full service agency with locations in Virginia Beach, Williamsburg and Harbour View. We are licensed in Virginia, North Carolina, Georgia, Maryland, Texas and West Virginia.

All of our locations offer a wide variety of insurance products including:

  • Automobile
  • Homeowners
  • Renters
  • Condo
  • Watercraft
  • Umbrella Liability
  • Life and Financial Services
  • Business/Commercial
  • Bonds

We pride ourselves in protecting our members and look forward to building long lasting relationships out of trust and friendship. We take the time to explain insurance – without jargon and carefully customize your insurance program to fit your unique needs.

Most importantly, we understand people do not care how much you know until they know how much you care.

Our History

Mayo Insurance has been serving clients since 1991 and has established a stellar reputation for service and professionalism. In 2006 we expanded our operations to include Williamsburg Insurance where we continue to serve clients with a high standard of quality and professionalism.

Both agencies offer a wide variety of insurance products including:

  • Automobile
  • Homeowners
  • Renters
  • Condo
  • Watercraft
  • Umbrella Liability
  • Life and Financial Services
  • Business/Commercial
  • Bonds

Why Mayo Insurance and Williamsburg Insurance?

3 Reasons:

  1. We explain what your policy does & doesn’t cover, because we think you have the right to understand what you’re paying for!
  2. We provide our customers with prompt service and efficient attention to detail.
  3. We are happy to offer periodic reviews of your policies and coverages because we know that insurance needs often change over time.

Our Locations

Virginia Beach
1917 Laskin Road
Ste. 101
Virginia Beach, VA 23454-4283
(757) 496-5685

Harbour View
5131 River Club Dr.
Ste. 120
Suffolk, VA 23435-3661
(757) 488-8440

Williamsburg
4324 New Town Ave.
Ste. B2
Williamsburg, VA 23188-2691
(757) 488-8440

Our Team

<center>C. Todd Mayo</center>

C. Todd Mayo

President

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
todd@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Todd founded the Mayo Insurance Agency in 1991.  He has over 25 years of insurance experience and is licensed in VA, NC, MD, GA, TX and WV for P&C and Life.  He is a graduate of First Colonial High School and also holds a BS/BA in Business Administration from East Carolina University.  Over the years Todd has achieved a diploma in Life Insurance Marketing, Certificate of Achievement in Business Lines, Advance Life, and Agency Development from Nationwide Insurance.  The agency has also achieved the Nationwide Champion and Presidents Conference Awards.

Todd is an active member of Kings Grant Baptist Church.  He also belongs to the Business Network International and Community Association Institute. When he is not at work Todd enjoys boating, going to the beach, landscaping and most important family time.

  • Licensed in: GA, MD, NC, TX, VA, WV
<center>Cory D. Mayo</center>

Cory D. Mayo

Associate Agent

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
cory@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Cory became a licensed insurance agent in 1994 when he joined his brother, Todd, at the Mayo Insurance Agency. He currently holds a P&C and Life license and has a broad knowledge of insurance which allows him to assist his clients as needed. He grew up in Virginia Beach and attended First Colonial High School. Cory is an active member at Kings Grant Baptist Church and is also a trustee for the Virginia Aquarium Foundation Board of Directors.  When he is not at work Cory enjoys spending time with his family, skiing and hiking.

  • Licensed in: MD, NC, VA
<center>Laura Whitney</center>

Laura Whitney

Manager/Agency Rep - Personal Lines - VB

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
laura@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Laura is a life-long Virginia Beach resident. She is a graduate of First Colonial High School and started her career in insurance in 2007. In early 2009 she joined the Mayo Insurance Agency team. Laura specializes in personal lines and life insurance. She is the manager of our Virginia Beach personal lines team and handles the office’s daily needs to keep things running smoothly. She is also a notary public for the office. In 2015 she had the opportunity to complete the Nationwide Law Enforcement and Corrections Certification Program in Columbus, OH. Laura enjoys spending time with her husband and their two daughters when she is not in the office.  She loves the outdoors, being creative and is an advocate for animal rights.

  • Licensed in: MD, NC, VA
<center>Heather McIlwee</center>

Heather McIlwee

Manager/Agency Rep – Commercial/Broker Lines - VB

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
heather@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Heather has been part of the Mayo Agency team since 2014. She happily assists our members with commercial insurance and specialty Homeowners insurance needs. Heather likes going to concerts in the summertime, and motorcycle riding. It is a family hobby that she enjoys with her husband, parents, aunt and uncle on the weekends.

  • Licensed in: VA
  • P&C and Life Licensed – VA and NC
<center>Penny McGroarty</center>

Penny McGroarty

Agency Rep - Personal Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
penny@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Penny started her insurance career in 1979 and began her employment with the agency in 2003 servicing our personal lines clients. She enjoys meeting her clients face-to-face the most.  Penny resides in Virginia Beach with her husband and enjoys boating and spending time with her family.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Karen McKee-Amato</center>

Karen McKee-Amato

Agency Rep - Personal Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
karen@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Originally from Long Island, New York, Karen now resides in Virginia with her husband and son. Karen originally came to Virginia to start a career in law enforcement but ended up switching gears and became a licensed Insurance Agent. She has now been part of our family at the Mayo Agency since May of 2011. Karen specializes in life insurance as well as property and casualty insurance. She enjoys spending time with her family at the beach and gym as well as bike riding, roller-blading and taking her Boxer on long walks. Karen’s impeccable dedication and determination has made her a favorite amongst our members; as she finds great joy in finding ways to save them money or helping them with a claim issue. Karen now feels Virginia is her second home, now if they could just get New York pizza and bagels!!

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Sherri McCrickard</center>

Sherri McCrickard

Agency Rep - Personal Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
sherri@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Sherri is originally from Pittsburgh, PA and resides in Virginia Beach with her husband. She has been with the Mayo Agency since 2007, and has specialized in personal lines of insurance since 1999. She is licensed in both P&C and Life Insurance. When she is away from work she enjoys being out on the water and boating with her husband, children and grandchildren.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Doris Rice</center>

Doris Rice

Agency Rep - Personal Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
doris@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

<center>Dehdra DiLorenzo</center>

Dehdra DiLorenzo

Agency Rep - Personal Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
dehdra@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

<center>Mever Lee</center>

Mever Lee

Agency Rep - Commercial/Broker Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
mever@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

I started my insurance journey with my dad in his insurance office in 1983. He retired and I went to work for Lovas Insurance, where I stayed for 27 years until he retired in 2018. The journey continued when the Mayo Agency took me in, I hope to work here until I retire! I was born and raised in Virginia Beach and the Outer Banks. I am married with 3 grown children. I enjoy spending time with my husband, my children and my many Grand-dogs! I also love the beach, fishing and sailing.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Donna Jones</center>

Donna Jones

Agency Rep – Commercial/Broker Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
donna@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Donna first became licensed in property/casualty insurance in 1999, working for several years at another local Nationwide agency before deciding to stay home and raise her two daughters. She became relicensed in 2013, and has been with the Mayo Agency ever since helping clients with business insurance and specialty homeowners insurance. To relax, she loves to watch Old Dominion University and Baltimore Ravens football. Donna also enjoys motorcycle rides in the country with her husband on their Harley Davidson.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Eliana Delgado</center>

Eliana Delgado

Agency Rep – Commercial/Broker Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
eliana@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Eliana is originally from Venezuela. She lived in Florida for 14 years before Moving to Virginia in August 2014. She now resides in Norfolk with her husband and her 7 year old silky terrier, Luna. She became licensed in 2001 and currently holds a P&C and Life insurance licenses. Eliana is bi-lingual and speaks fluent Spanish. Her family and son are very important to her. When away from work, she enjoys the beach, the movies and being out with friends.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Candice Carouge</center>

Candice Carouge

Agency Rep – Commercial/Broker Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
candice@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Candice is originally from a small farm on the Eastern Shore in Maryland. She was raised there along with her two siblings by her wonderful parents.  She started working in the insurance industry in 2015 with a Nationwide agency in Maryland. In 2018 she moved to Virginia and joined our Commercial/Brokerage team. When Candice is not in the office she enjoys spending time with her family, and doing anything outdoors. Her favorite sports are hunting, fishing, sailing, kayaking, boating and cackling really loud!

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Elle Hatton</center>

Elle Hatton

Agency Rep – Commercial/Broker Lines

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
elle@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Elle was born and raised in Fredericksburg, VA, moving to Virginia Beach with her family in 1998. After graduating, Elle traveled around the country for about ten years and got to experience life in many different places. She has found that she really prefers the warmer climates and living places where flip flops are a part of daily life. Elle has around 10 years of insurance experience, both on the sales and service side along with the underwriting side as well. She greatly enjoys helping her customers to understand their insurance and assisting them with getting the best coverage for their needs. When she isn’t working, she can usually be found on a beach with a book and her 2 pups.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Jennifer Eason</center>

Jennifer Eason

Certificate Specialist – Virginia Beach

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
certificates@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Jenn was born in Massachusetts but has lived all over the US and in Europe. Her father was in the Air Force for 25 years, which allowed her to live in 9 states as well as Greece and Italy. She has traveled to over 30 states in the US either by way of the military or just by driving on road trips. She moved to Virginia in 1997 and have lived back and forth between Virginia and Maine throughout the years. She now permanently resides in Virginia Beach with her husband of 14 years.

Jenn started with the Mayo Insurance Agency in March 2018 as a certificate specialist with our commercial department. She absolutely loves what she does and most of all the people she works with.

When Jenn is not at work she loves to spend as much time as she can with her family. She also enjoys shopping, road trips, playing board or card games and she loves to watch all sports related to New England teams. She is a dedicated fan to the Boston Red Sox, Boston Bruins, Boston Celtics, and New England Patriots.

<center>Sabrina Saat</center>

Sabrina Saat

Commercial/Broker Lines Assistant

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
sabrina@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Sabrina was born in Kentucky but has lived up and down the east coast with her Navy family. She now resides in Virginia and joined the agency in August of 2018. Sabrina holds a P&C license and happy to join our Commercial/Brokerage team. When Sabrina is not in the office, she can be found spending time with her boyfriend, friends and family. Her favorite things to do are baking, arts & crafts and learning the ukulele!

<center>Rhianna Fanning</center>

Rhianna Fanning

Receptionist – Virginia Beach

Phone: (757) 496-5685
Fax: (757) 496-5682
reception@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Rhianna joined our Virginia Beach team in August of 2018. She always answers the phones and greets our clients with a smile! She’s an excellent team player and assists everyone in the office on a variety of tasks. She is originally from Jacksonville, FL and moved around most of her childhood until ending up in Virginia Beach. She has two children, who are the center of her life, and plans on marrying the love of her life in 2019. When not at work she enjoys hanging out with her children and her fiancé. During the summer they love going to the beach and Busch Gardens in Williamsburg.

<center>Shawn Conlogue</center>

Shawn Conlogue

Manager/Agency Rep – Harbour View

Phone: (757) 488-8440
Fax: (757) 488-4881
shawn@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Shawn has been in the insurance industry 1992. She worked with the Nationwide affiliated John Dobson Insurance Agency prior to joining our team in 2017, upon John Dobson’s retirement. Shawn became the manager of our Harbour View location upon this merger.

She is married and is the mother of 2 grown children and has 3 grandchildren. Shawn is a member of Believers Church. In her spare time she enjoys reading, gardening, and spending quality time with family & friends.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Dana Dubois</center>

Dana Dubois

Agency Rep – Harbour View

Phone: (757) 488-8440
Fax: (757) 488-4881
dana@mayoinsuranceagency.com

More

Dana became a licensed agent in 1997. She currently holds her P&C and Life license. Dana joined the Mayo team when we merged with the Dobson Insurance Agency in 2017. Dana is married and has one son who is also married. When Dana is not in the office she attends church, likes going to the beach, watching sports, and hanging out with her family and friends.

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Cindy Kelley</center>

Cindy Kelley

Receptionist - Harbour View

More

<center>Elaine Obie</center>

Elaine Obie

Associate Agent/Office Manager - Williamsburg

Phone: (757) 476-5816
Fax: (757) 476-5820
elaine@williamsburginsuranceagency.com

More

Elaine offers a history of success within the insurance industry by applying strong business acumen, statistical analysis and leadership talents.   She is comfortable creating a plan for success and following through. 

Most recently, Elaine became a Licensed Agent with Nationwide Insurance.  Her current office opened in 2006.  Within 3 years of opening the current office she was recognized by the Williamsburg community as “Insurance Agent of the Year.”  She continues to grow her business by utilizing her background in Compliance, Marketing, Producing, Balancing Budget Expenses and Educating staff.  Elaine’s experience includes Claims, Operations and Agency departments.  This experience provides her with a broad perspective to resolve insurance needs for the benefit of my clients. 

Elaine’s focus on community collaboration has led to several volunteer positions including, Board Chair Community Table Project,  Advisory Board Member at the Salvation Army and Business Watch Coordinator in New Town.  Additionally, she works closely with the James City County Police department to help promote several community awareness programs such as Identity Theft and Non Drinking and Driving campaigns.

  • Licensed in VA

<center>Brenda Williams</center>

Brenda Williams

Agency Rep – Williamsburg

Phone: (757) 476-5816
Fax: (757) 476-5820
brenda@williamsburginsuranceagency.com

More

Brenda has thirty plus years of experience in the insurance industry.  The first part of her insurance career was spent on the corporate side in commercial underwriting.  For the past ten years she has been on the agency side of the insurance industry.   Her previous clients on the corporate side were the agents that submitted the business and now her clients are the general public.  Huge difference and she enjoys both.

Her education has been mostly from on the job experience.  Brenda has taken classes to obtain her property and casualty state insurance license as well as life and health. 

Brenda enjoys riding on the back of her husband’s Honda Goldwing as well as traveling to places she has not yet experienced.  Her grandchildren are her pride and joy, especially her granddaughter.  Brenda loves shopping with her and experiencing all of the joys that growing up are bringing her.

  • Licensed in VA
<center>Kathy Marable</center>

Kathy Marable

Agency Rep – Williamsburg

Phone: (757) 476-5816
Fax: (757) 476-5820
kathy@williamsburginsuranceagency.com

More

  • Licensed in: VA
<center>Certificates Of Insurance</center>

Certificates Of Insurance

More

Please email any of your certificate of insurance requests to certificates@mayoinsuranceagency.com.